Body Recomposition: The Holy Grail

Losing fat while building muscle simultaneously. It's possible—but not for everyone, and not forever.

---

## 📖 The Story

Alex had a classic dilemma: too much fat to want to bulk, not enough muscle to want to cut. At 180 pounds and roughly 25% body fat, neither direction felt right.

"If I bulk, I'll just get fatter. If I cut, I'll look skinny. What do I do?"

The fitness internet offered conflicting advice. Some said it was impossible to lose fat and gain muscle at the same time—you have to pick one. Others promised he could "recomp" his way to a lean, muscular physique without ever bulking or cutting.

Here's the truth: Body recomposition is real, but it's not for everyone, and it's not forever.

Research consistently shows that certain populations can lose fat and gain muscle simultaneously. But it's a slower path than focused phases, and it becomes increasingly difficult as you become more trained and leaner.

Alex, as a beginner with excess body fat, was actually in the ideal position for recomposition. His body had the energy stores (fat) to fuel muscle growth and the novelty response (untrained) that makes muscle gains easier.

Six months later, Alex weighed the same—180 pounds—but looked completely different. His body fat had dropped to 18%, and he'd gained measurable muscle. The scale didn't move, but his body transformed.

That's body recomposition.

---

## 🚶 The Journey

Who Recomp Works For

Ideal candidates:

1. Beginners (first 1-2 years of lifting)

   • Novel training stimulus = rapid adaptation
   • Newbie gains allow muscle growth in almost any caloric state

2. Returning lifters (after layoff)

   • "Muscle memory" (myonuclear domain theory)
   • Previously trained muscle regains faster

3. Overweight/obese individuals

   • Large fat stores provide energy
   • Hormonal environment often supports growth
   • More "room" for improvement

4. Those with higher body fat (men >20%, women >28%)

   • Fat stores fuel muscle protein synthesis
   • Not fighting extreme leanness adaptations

Who Should NOT Expect Recomp

Poor candidates:

1. Experienced lifters (3+ years consistent training)

   • Near genetic potential
   • Body resists simultaneous gains

2. Already lean individuals (men <15%, women <22%)

   • Not enough fat stores
   • Hormonal resistance to deficits

3. Advanced trainees wanting significant change

   • Too slow for meaningful progress
   • Focused phases are more efficient

The Timeline

Months 1-3:

• Weight may fluctuate but trend stable
• Strength should increase
• Measurements may not change yet
• Building the foundation

Months 3-6:

• Visual changes become apparent
• Clothes fit differently
• Photos show transformation
• Scale may still be stable

Months 6-12:

• Continued progress (if eligible)
• Assess: Is it still working?
• Decision point: continue or switch

Beyond 12 months:

• Progress likely slows
• Consider focused phases
• Recomp becomes maintenance

---

## 🧠 The Science

Is It Really Possible?

The Research Says: Yes

Meta-analysis findings (Murphy et al.):

"Being in a deficit clearly reduced muscle gain, but most participants training around maintenance still increased lean mass."

Key insight: At maintenance calories, recomposition is a regular outcome in research studies, not an exception.

The Magnitude Trade-off

Approach	Fat Loss	Muscle Gain	Speed
Cut (500 cal deficit)	Optimal	Minimal/None	Fastest fat loss
Recomp (maintenance)	Moderate	Moderate	Slowest overall
Bulk (300 cal surplus)	None/Gain	Optimal	Fastest muscle gain

The math: Recomposition is possible but slower because you're doing two things at once instead of optimizing for one.

Why It Works for Some

Energy partitioning: In certain conditions, the body can:

• Use stored fat for energy
• Direct dietary protein toward muscle synthesis
• Result: net fat loss + net muscle gain

Conditions that enable this:

• High body fat (large energy reserve)
• Training novelty (strong growth signal)
• Adequate protein (building blocks available)
• Sufficient stimulus (resistance training)

Deficit Size Matters

The Deficit Threshold

Research finding (2021 meta-analysis):

"As soon as the deficit surpassed around 300 calories, muscle growth came to a halt. Deficits larger than 500 calories actively impaired hypertrophy."

Deficit	Effect on Muscle Growth
0 (maintenance)	Normal growth possible
100-300 cal	Slightly reduced but still possible
300-500 cal	Significantly impaired
>500 cal	Growth essentially stops; may lose muscle

Recomp Sweet Spot

For recomposition, aim for:

• Maintenance calories, OR
• Very small deficit (100-300 cal max)

Why not a larger deficit?

• Fat loss would be faster, yes
• But muscle gain stops
• You'd be doing a cut, not a recomp

Practical Calculation

1. Find your TDEE (Total Daily Energy Expenditure)
2. For recomp: Eat at TDEE or up to 300 below
3. Set protein at 1g/lb body weight or higher

Example (180 lb person, TDEE ~2,400):

• Recomp calories: 2,100-2,400
• Protein: 180g minimum
• Remaining calories: carbs and fat based on preference

Protein Is Critical

Higher Protein for Recomp

When eating at maintenance or slight deficit, protein becomes even more important than during a surplus.

Research recommendations:

Context	Protein Target
Surplus (bulk)	1.6 g/kg (0.7 g/lb)
Maintenance (recomp)	2.0-2.4 g/kg (0.9-1.1 g/lb)
Deficit (cut)	2.3-3.1 g/kg lean mass

Why higher for recomp?

• No excess calories to spare protein
• Every gram must be optimized for MPS
• Higher intake = insurance against loss

Protein Distribution for Recomp

Spreading protein across meals may matter more during recomp:

• 4+ meals per day with 25-40g protein each
• Pre/post workout nutrition more important
• Pre-sleep protein (casein or slow-digesting) may help

---

## 👀 Signs & Signals

You're Successfully Recomping

Signal	What It Looks Like
Weight stable	±3-5 lbs fluctuation, but monthly average stable
Strength increasing	Progressive overload continuing
Measurements changing	Waist smaller, arms/chest same or larger
Photos show change	Monthly comparison reveals transformation
Clothes fit differently	Looser waist, tighter sleeves
Body fat % dropping	If measured (DEXA, calipers)

Warning Signs

Signal	What It Means	Action
Strength dropping	Deficit too aggressive OR poor recovery	Increase calories slightly, check sleep
Losing weight rapidly	You're cutting, not recomping	Increase calories to maintenance
Gaining weight rapidly	You're bulking, not recomping	Reduce calories slightly
No changes in 8+ weeks	Recomp may not be working for you	Consider focused phases
Constant hunger	May be under-eating	Verify you're at maintenance

Measuring Recomp Progress

Traditional metrics don't work well for recomposition because weight stays stable. Instead:

Track these:

• Progress photos (weekly or bi-weekly)
• Waist measurement (should decrease)
• Arm/chest/thigh measurements (should maintain or increase)
• Strength on key lifts (should increase)
• Body fat percentage (if accessible)

Don't rely on:

• Scale weight (will stay flat)
• BMI (meaningless for recomp)

---

## 🎯 Practical Application

Getting Started

Step 1: Determine Eligibility

Good candidate if:

• New to lifting (<2 years consistent)
• Body fat >20% (men) or >28% (women)
• Returning after significant break
• Haven't maximized newbie gains yet

Poor candidate if:

• Training 3+ years consistently
• Already lean (<15% men, <22% women)
• Want rapid visible change
• Near genetic potential

Step 2: Set Your Numbers

Calories:

1. Calculate TDEE (maintenance calories)
2. Eat at TDEE or up to 300 below
3. Don't go lower—you'll stop building muscle

Protein:

• 1g per pound body weight minimum
• Higher is fine (up to 1.2g/lb)

Example Setup (200 lb male, estimated 25% BF):

• TDEE: ~2,600 calories
• Recomp target: 2,300-2,600 calories
• Protein: 200g (minimum)
• Remaining: ~1,500-1,800 calories from carbs/fat

Step 3: Training Setup

Requirements:

• Resistance training 3-4x per week minimum
• Progressive overload focus
• Compound movements priority
• Full body or upper/lower split

Cardio:

• Optional for recomp
• If included: moderate amounts (2-3x/week)
• Don't let it impair recovery

Daily Execution

Recomp Day Example (~2,400 calories, 200g protein)

Breakfast (500 cal, 40g protein):

• 4 egg whites + 2 whole eggs
• 2 slices whole grain toast
• Greek yogurt (plain)

Lunch (600 cal, 50g protein):

• 6oz chicken breast
• Large salad with olive oil dressing
• 1/2 cup rice

Pre-workout snack (250 cal, 30g protein):

• Protein shake
• Banana

Post-workout (600 cal, 50g protein):

• 6oz lean beef
• Large portion vegetables
• Sweet potato

Evening (450 cal, 30g protein):

• Cottage cheese
• Berries
• Small handful almonds

Total: ~2,400 calories, ~200g protein

Weekly Structure

Day	Activity
Monday	Upper body (push focus)
Tuesday	Lower body
Wednesday	Rest or light cardio
Thursday	Upper body (pull focus)
Friday	Lower body
Saturday	Optional light activity
Sunday	Rest

What to Expect

Month-by-Month Expectations

Month 1:

• Weight: Stable (±2-3 lbs)
• Strength: Increasing
• Visual: No noticeable change
• Measurements: Minimal change

Month 2:

• Weight: Still stable
• Strength: Continued increase
• Visual: Possible slight change
• Measurements: Waist may drop 0.5"

Month 3:

• Weight: Stable
• Strength: Increasing
• Visual: Noticeable in photos
• Measurements: More change visible

Month 4-6:

• Weight: Stable (maybe down slightly)
• Strength: Continued progress
• Visual: Clear transformation in comparison photos
• Measurements: Waist down, arms/chest same or up

When to Reassess

At 3 months, evaluate:

• Is strength still increasing? If no → consider surplus
• Is waist still shrinking? If no → consider deficit
• Are you satisfied with pace? If no → consider focused phases

At 6 months:

• Major decision point
• Continue if still progressing
• Switch to focused phases if stalled

---

## 📸 What It Looks Like

Realistic Recomp Timeline (180 lb male, 25% BF start)

Month	Weight	Est. BF%	Notes
Start	180	25%	Beginning
2	180	23%	Subtle changes, strength up
4	179	21%	Visible in photos
6	178	19%	Clear transformation
9	178	17%	Approaching switch point
12	178	16%	Consider focused phase

What changed:

• Lost ~16 lbs of fat (45 → 29 lbs)
• Gained ~14 lbs of muscle
• Net weight: -2 lbs
• Visual change: Dramatic

Comparison: Recomp vs. Focused Phases

Same starting point, different approaches:

Recomp (12 months):

• Start: 180 lbs, 25% BF
• End: 178 lbs, 16% BF
• Slow, steady transformation

Cut then Bulk (12 months):

• Start: 180 lbs, 25% BF
• After 4-month cut: 160 lbs, 15% BF
• After 8-month bulk: 175 lbs, 18% BF
• Faster fat loss, more muscle gain potential

Which is better?

• Recomp: Simpler, never feel "small" from cutting
• Focused phases: Faster results, more optimization required
• Personal preference matters

---

## 🚀 Getting Started

Week 1: Assessment and Setup

Day 1-2:

• Determine if you're a good recomp candidate
• Calculate TDEE and protein target
• Set up tracking (food app, workout log)

Day 3-4:

• Take baseline photos (front, side, back)
• Record measurements (waist, arms, chest, thighs)
• Weigh yourself (will track weekly average)

Day 5-7:

• Start eating at maintenance with high protein
• Begin or continue resistance training program
• Establish the routine

Month 1: Foundation

Focus:

• Hit protein daily (non-negotiable)
• Train 3-4x/week with progressive overload
• Weigh daily, track weekly average
• Don't expect visible changes yet

Adjust if:

• Losing weight rapidly → increase calories
• Gaining weight → decrease calories
• Goal: weight stable

Months 2-3: Consistency

Focus:

• Continue the routine
• Track strength progress
• Take progress photos monthly
• Trust the process

Expect:

• Strength increases
• Subtle visual changes
• Measurements may start changing

Months 4-6: Assessment

Evaluate:

• Compare photos (start vs. now)
• Review strength logs
• Check measurements
• Decide: continue or switch?

If progressing: Continue recomp If stalled: Switch to focused phases

---

## 🔧 Troubleshooting

Problem	Likely Cause	Solution
Losing weight	Eating below maintenance	Increase calories 100-200
Gaining weight	Eating above maintenance	Decrease calories 100-200
Strength stalled	Under-recovery or plateau	Deload week, check sleep/protein
No visual change after 2+ months	May not be good recomp candidate	Consider focused phases
Constantly hungry	May need more food	Slight calorie increase, more protein/fiber
Losing strength	Under-eating	Increase calories, verify protein
Only losing fat, not gaining muscle	Deficit too large	Increase to true maintenance
Gaining fat while gaining muscle	Surplus too large	Decrease calories slightly

---

❓ Common Questions

Q: Can everyone do body recomposition? A: No. It works best for beginners, returning lifters, and those with higher body fat. Experienced, lean individuals should use focused phases instead.

Q: How long does recomp take? A: Expect 3-6 months for noticeable changes. It's slower than focused phases but avoids the "small" phase of cutting or the "fluffy" phase of bulking.

Q: Should I do cardio during recomp? A: Optional. Moderate cardio is fine, but don't overdo it—recovery matters. Prioritize resistance training.

Q: Why isn't the scale moving? A: That's the point! You're losing fat and gaining muscle, which may cancel out on the scale. Track progress through photos, measurements, and strength instead.

Q: How much muscle can I gain during recomp? A: Beginners: 1-2 lbs/month. Intermediates: 0.5-1 lb/month. Advanced: 0-0.5 lb/month. Less than a true surplus, but still meaningful.

Q: When should I switch from recomp to focused phases? A: When progress stalls for 6-8 weeks despite good adherence, or when you've been recomping for 6-12 months and want faster results.

Q: Is recomp slower than bulking and cutting? A: Usually, yes. You're optimizing for two goals at once. Focused phases are faster for each individual goal, but recomp avoids the extremes.

---

⚖️ Where Research Disagrees

Topic	View A	View B	Current Consensus
Is recomp possible?	Myth—pick one goal	Real and achievable	Real, but population-dependent
Deficit size	Small deficit enables growth	Any deficit stops growth	Up to ~300 cal deficit may allow growth
Protein amount	Standard 1.6 g/kg sufficient	Need higher (2.4+ g/kg)	Higher is better for recomp
Who can recomp	Anyone	Only specific populations	Beginners, overweight, detrained
Timeline	Indefinitely	Only short-term	Works best for 6-12 months
Optimal strategy	Always recomp	Always focused phases	Depends on individual and goals

---

✅ Quick Reference

Eligibility Check:

• Beginner (<2 years lifting)?
• Higher body fat (>20% men, >28% women)?
• Returning after break?

If 2+ checked: Good candidate for recomp

Key Numbers:

• Calories: Maintenance or up to 300 below
• Protein: 1g per lb body weight
• Training: 3-4x/week resistance training

Daily Checklist:

• Hit protein target
• Ate at maintenance (±100 cal)
• Trained or recovered
• Logged food and workout

Weekly Checklist:

• Weight average stable (±2-3 lbs)
• Progressive overload achieved
• Recovery adequate

Monthly Checklist:

• Progress photos taken
• Measurements recorded
• Strength log reviewed
• Compared to previous month

Decision Points:

• 3 months: Evaluate progress, adjust if needed
• 6 months: Major assessment—continue or switch?
• 12 months: Consider transitioning to focused phases

---

💡 Key Takeaways

Essential Insights

• Body recomposition is real—research consistently shows simultaneous fat loss and muscle gain at maintenance calories.
• It's not for everyone: Best for beginners, returning lifters, and those with higher body fat.
• Deficit size matters: Stay at maintenance or max 300 cal below. Larger deficits stop muscle growth.
• Protein is critical: 1g per lb body weight minimum; higher is better for recomp.
• It's slower than focused phases. Trade-off: avoid the extremes of bulk/cut, but progress takes longer.
• Track differently: Scale won't move. Use photos, measurements, and strength instead.
• Know when to switch: If stalled for 6-8 weeks, consider focused phases instead.

---

🔗 Connections

Related Goals:

• Fat Loss - When to switch to a dedicated cut
• Muscle Building - When to switch to a dedicated bulk
• Maintenance - Sustaining your results
• Tracking - How to measure recomp progress

Wellness Foundations:

• Metabolism - Energy balance fundamentals
• Protein - Protein optimization
• Strength Training - Training for recomp

Personalization:

• Goal Setting - Setting realistic recomp expectations
• Self-Assessment - Determining if recomp is right for you

---

For Mo

Assessment Questions

Ask these to determine if recomp is appropriate:

1. How long have you been lifting? (<2 years = good candidate)
2. What's your estimated body fat percentage? (>20% men, >28% women = good candidate)
3. Have you lifted before and taken a break? (Yes = good candidate, muscle memory)
4. What's your primary goal—fat loss or muscle gain? (If strongly one, focused phase may be better)
5. How patient are you with progress? (Impatient = focused phases, patient = recomp okay)
6. What's your training experience level? (Advanced = unlikely to recomp successfully)

Quick Eligibility Decision

Profile	Recommendation
Beginner + higher BF	Great recomp candidate
Beginner + lean	Small surplus (lean bulk)
Intermediate + higher BF	Recomp possible OR cut first
Intermediate + lean	Focused phases (bulk or cut)
Advanced + any BF	Focused phases only
Returning after layoff	Recomp works well

Implementation Intentions

Help users create specific if-then plans:

Nutrition:

• "When I eat a meal, I will ensure it has at least 30g of protein."
• "If I'm not sure about calories, I will track everything for that day."
• "When the scale moves more than 3 lbs in a week, I will adjust calories."

Tracking:

• "On Sunday mornings, I will take progress photos."
• "After each workout, I will log weights and reps."
• "On the 1st of each month, I will take measurements."

Assessment:

• "After 3 months, I will compare photos and decide if I should continue or switch."
• "If strength stalls for 3 weeks, I will take a deload and reassess nutrition."

Common Mistakes to Catch

Watch for these patterns:

1. Wrong candidate trying recomp (advanced lifter, already lean) → Redirect to focused phases
2. Too large a deficit ("I'm eating 1,500 calories") → That's a cut, not recomp; increase to maintenance
3. Obsessing over scale weight → Reframe: scale won't move, track other metrics
4. Expecting fast results → Set realistic timeline expectations (6+ months)
5. Not enough protein → Emphasize 1g/lb minimum for recomp
6. Skipping resistance training → Resistance training is non-negotiable
7. Too much cardio → May interfere with recovery; moderate only

Red Flags for Professional Referral

Recommend professional support when:

• Signs of body dysmorphia (never satisfied, always wanting to change) → Therapist
• Disordered eating patterns (extreme restriction, bingeing) → Eating disorder specialist
• Medical conditions affecting body composition → Physician
• Unrealistic expectations despite education → May benefit from coaching
• Significant stress about body affecting daily life → Mental health professional

Example Scenarios

Scenario 1: Good candidate uncertain

User: "I'm new to lifting, about 22% body fat. Should I bulk or cut first?"

Mo response: "You're actually in an ideal position for body recomposition—where you lose fat and gain muscle at the same time. As a beginner with moderate body fat, your body can do both efficiently. Here's what I'd suggest: eat at maintenance calories (not surplus, not big deficit), get 1g of protein per pound body weight, and lift consistently 3-4x/week. The scale may not move much, but your body composition will change. After 3-6 months, we can reassess. Want me to help you calculate your maintenance calories?"

Scenario 2: Poor candidate wanting recomp

User: "I've been lifting for 4 years and I'm at 14% body fat. Can I recomp to get more muscle without getting fatter?"

Mo response: "I appreciate you wanting the best of both worlds, but I want to be honest: at your training level and body fat percentage, recomposition is unlikely to produce meaningful results. You're past the 'newbie gains' phase where the body easily builds muscle in any caloric state. For you, focused phases will be more effective—a controlled surplus to build muscle, then a cut to reveal it. The good news: with your experience, you can run short, efficient bulk and cut cycles. Would you like to explore a lean bulk approach?"

Scenario 3: Scale anxiety

User: "I've been recomping for 6 weeks but the scale hasn't moved. Is it working?"

Mo response: "That's actually the expected outcome with recomposition! The scale stays stable because you're losing fat and gaining muscle simultaneously—they cancel out on the scale. The question is: what do other metrics show? How are your lifts progressing—getting stronger? How do your clothes fit? Do your progress photos show any change compared to week 1? These are the real indicators of recomp success, not scale weight. If strength is increasing and photos show subtle changes, you're on track."

Scenario 4: Impatient with progress

User: "I've been doing recomp for 3 months and the changes are so slow. Should I just do a hard cut?"

Mo response: "I hear you—recomp is slower than focused phases, and that's frustrating. The trade-off is you avoid feeling 'small' from cutting or 'fluffy' from bulking. But if speed matters more to you now, a dedicated cut can work. Here's the decision: Do you want to look leaner faster and accept some muscle loss? Or stay the course for the gradual transformation? There's no wrong answer—it depends on your priorities. If you switch to a cut, plan for maintenance/recomp after to preserve what you've built. What matters more to you right now—speed or the smoother path?"

---

❓ Common Questions

Q: Is body recomposition actually possible or just a myth?

Short answer: Yes, it's real—but it works best for specific populations.

The science: Your body can simultaneously build muscle and lose fat when:

• You're new to resistance training (strongest effect)
• You're returning after a break (muscle memory)
• You're carrying significant body fat (fuel available)
• You're using performance-enhancing drugs (not recommended)

Who it works best for:

• Complete beginners (first 6-12 months of lifting)
• Overweight individuals starting resistance training
• People returning to training after time off
• Those with poor previous nutrition now optimizing

Who should choose focused phases instead:

• Advanced lifters (3+ years consistent training)
• Already lean individuals (<15% male, <22% female)
• Anyone wanting faster results

---

Q: How long does body recomposition take to see results?

Timeline expectations:

Metric	When You'll Notice
Strength gains	2-4 weeks
Clothes fitting differently	4-8 weeks
Visual changes in mirror	6-12 weeks
Clear progress photos	12-16 weeks
Significant transformation	6-12 months

Why it feels slow:

• Scale doesn't move (fat loss and muscle gain cancel out)
• Changes are gradual and subtle
• You see yourself daily, so changes are hard to notice
• No dramatic "reveal" like after a cut

How to track properly:

• Weekly progress photos (same lighting, time, poses)
• Strength progression (are lifts going up?)
• Measurements (waist, arms, thighs)
• How clothes fit
• NOT the scale (it will deceive you)

---

Q: What should I eat for body recomposition?

The key principles:

Factor	Target	Notes
Calories	Maintenance (±100)	Slight surplus or deficit both work
Protein	1g per lb bodyweight	Non-negotiable; higher than cutting/bulking
Training	Resistance 3-4x/week	Progressive overload essential

Practical approach:

• Calculate TDEE (maintenance calories)
• Hit protein target first
• Fill remaining calories with carbs and fats
• Don't stress about perfect macros beyond protein

Common mistakes:

• Eating too little (that's a cut, not recomp)
• Eating too much (that's a bulk, not recomp)
• Not prioritizing protein
• Expecting scale movement

---

Q: Should I do cardio during body recomposition?

Short answer: Some is fine, but don't overdo it.

Guidelines:

Cardio Type	Recommendation	Rationale
Daily walking	Encouraged (8,000+ steps)	Doesn't interfere with recovery
Low-intensity (Zone 2)	2-3x/week, 20-30 min	Good for health, minimal interference
High-intensity (HIIT)	1-2x/week max	Can impair recovery if overdone
Excessive cardio	Avoid	Interferes with muscle building

Priority order:

1. Resistance training (non-negotiable)
2. Daily walking/movement
3. Some cardio for health
4. Not so much cardio it hurts recovery

---

Q: How do I know if recomposition is working if the scale doesn't move?

Track these metrics instead:

Metric	What to Look For	Frequency
Progress photos	Visible changes in muscle definition	Every 2-4 weeks
Strength	Weights going up on main lifts	Every workout
Measurements	Waist down, arms/chest up	Every 2-4 weeks
Clothes fit	Looser waist, tighter arms	Ongoing
Energy levels	Consistent, not depleted	Daily

Signs recomp IS working:

• Getting stronger in the gym
• Waist measurement decreasing
• Arm/shoulder measurements stable or increasing
• Clothes fit better (looser pants, tighter shirts in arms)
• Progress photos show subtle changes

Signs recomp ISN'T working:

• Strength stalling for weeks
• No visual changes after 12+ weeks
• Measurements not changing
• (In this case, switch to focused phases)

---

Q: Can advanced lifters do body recomposition?

Short answer: Generally not worth it.

Why it's harder for advanced lifters:

• Already close to genetic potential
• Body has adapted to resistance training
• Muscle protein synthesis response is smaller
• Fat loss requires deficit, muscle gain requires surplus
• The two processes compete more directly

Better approach for advanced lifters:

• Lean bulk: Small surplus (200-300 cal) to minimize fat gain
• Mini-cuts: Short 4-6 week cutting phases
• Maintenance phases: Consolidate gains between phases
• Accept that progress will be slower regardless of approach

Exception: If returning from a layoff, you can "recomp" via muscle memory effect.

---

✅ Quick Reference

Who Should Recomp?

Candidate	Recomp?	Better Alternative
Complete beginner	✅ Yes	—
Returning after break	✅ Yes	—
Overweight + new to lifting	✅ Yes	—
Intermediate lifter, moderate BF	⚠️ Maybe	Lean bulk/mini-cut cycles
Advanced lifter	❌ No	Focused bulk/cut phases
Already lean	❌ No	Lean bulk

Recomp Targets

Metric	Target Range	Notes
Calories	Maintenance (TDEE)	±100 calories
Protein	1g per lb bodyweight	Critical for recomp
Resistance training	3-4x per week	Progressive overload
Cardio	Moderate	Don't overdo it
Sleep	7-9 hours	Recovery essential

Do's and Don'ts

Do:

• Track progress photos (not just scale)
• Prioritize protein intake
• Focus on getting stronger
• Be patient (6+ months timeline)
• Track measurements

Don't:

• Obsess over scale weight
• Expect rapid results
• Do excessive cardio
• Eat in a large deficit (that's cutting)
• Compare to people on focused phases

Progress Tracking for Recomp

Metric	Track?	How Often
Scale weight	Optional	Weekly average (for reference only)
Progress photos	✅ Essential	Every 2-4 weeks
Strength numbers	✅ Essential	Every workout
Measurements	✅ Essential	Every 2-4 weeks
Body fat %	Optional	Monthly (if accurate method)

When to Switch Approaches

Situation	Action
No progress after 3-4 months	Switch to focused phases
Strength stalling repeatedly	May need caloric surplus
Want faster fat loss	Switch to dedicated cut
Want faster muscle gain	Switch to dedicated bulk
Reached intermediate level	Consider focused phases

---

📚 Sources

Primary Sources (Tier A)

• Murphy C, et al. Energy deficit impacts lean mass gain during resistance training: A meta-regression analysis. Int J Sport Nutr Exerc Metab. 2021. —
• Barakat C, et al. Body Recomposition: Can Trained Individuals Build Muscle and Lose Fat at the Same Time? Strength Cond J. 2020. —

Supporting Sources (Tier B)

• Slater GJ, et al. Is an Energy Surplus Required to Maximize Skeletal Muscle Hypertrophy Associated With Resistance Training. Front Nutr. 2019. —
• Trexler ET. Building Muscle in a Caloric Deficit: Context is Key. Stronger by Science. 2023. —
• Helms ER, et al. Evidence-based recommendations for natural bodybuilding contest preparation. JISSN. 2014. —

Expert Sources (Tier C)

• Aragon AA. AARR Research Review. Body recomposition analysis. —
• Norton L. Gains during a calorie deficit: fact or fiction? Biolayne. —