Skip to main content

Probiotics

Understanding and using beneficial bacteria supplementation effectively.

📖 The Story​

Click to expand

Sarah stood in the supplement aisle, overwhelmed. Forty different probiotic products, each claiming to be the best. 10 billion CFUs. 50 billion CFUs. 100 billion CFUs. Multiple strains. Single strains. Refrigerated. Shelf-stable.

"How do I even choose?" she thought.

Her functional medicine doctor later explained: "Most people approach probiotics wrong. They think more is better, any strain works the same, and that probiotics are for everyone. None of that is true."

Sarah learned that specific strains matter for specific issues. That more CFUs isn't always better. That some people shouldn't take probiotics at all until they address underlying issues. And that food-based probiotics might be just as valuable as supplements.

Armed with better understanding, she chose a targeted probiotic for her specific concern, at an appropriate dose, and gave it a proper trial. It helped—but more importantly, she understood why.

The lesson: Probiotics aren't one-size-fits-all. Effective use requires understanding strains, doses, and whether they're even appropriate for your situation.

🚶 The Journey​

Understanding Probiotics

Key Terminology:

TermExampleWhat It Means
GenusLactobacillusGeneral category
SpeciesacidophilusMore specific
StrainLA-5Most specific—research applies to strain
CFU10 billionColony-forming units (amount)

Important: Research on one strain doesn't apply to another, even within the same species.

🧠 The Science​

How Probiotics Work

Mechanisms of Action​

1. Competitive Exclusion:

  • Occupy space pathogens could use
  • Consume nutrients pathogens need
  • Temporary "good crowd" effect

2. Antimicrobial Production:

  • Produce bacteriocins (natural antibiotics)
  • Produce organic acids (lower pH)
  • Create inhospitable environment for pathogens

3. Immune Modulation:

  • Interact with gut immune cells
  • Can reduce or increase immune activity
  • Strain-specific effects

4. Barrier Support:

  • Stimulate mucus production
  • Support tight junction proteins
  • Reduce permeability

5. Metabolite Production:

  • Some produce SCFAs
  • Some produce vitamins
  • Strain-dependent

Do They Colonize?​

Generally No:

  • Most strains pass through without permanent establishment
  • Benefits occur while present
  • May influence resident bacteria
  • Need continued intake for continued effect

Exception:

  • Some strains may persist longer
  • Very young (developing microbiome) more colonization-prone
  • After antibiotics may be more receptive

Research-Supported Uses​

ConditionEvidence LevelNotes
Antibiotic-associated diarrheaStrongTake during/after antibiotics
C. difficile preventionStrongSpecific strains
IBS symptomsModerateStrain-dependent
Infectious diarrhea (duration)StrongEspecially in children
Eczema prevention (infants)ModerateSpecific strains, timing matters
Vaginal healthModerateSpecific Lactobacillus strains
Upper respiratory infectionsModerateSome strains reduce duration
Anxiety/depressionEmergingPsychobiotics, modest effects

What Research Doesn't Support​

  • "Boosting" immunity generically
  • Weight loss (limited, inconsistent)
  • Replacing diverse diet
  • Treating all gut issues
  • Universal benefit for everyone
## đź‘€ Signs & Signals

Signs Probiotics May Help​

SituationWhy Probiotics Might Help
Taking antibioticsPrevent diarrhea, support recovery
Recent gut infectionRestore beneficial bacteria
IBS symptomsSome strains reduce symptoms
Frequent minor infectionsImmune support
Post-travel digestive issuesCompete with problematic organisms

Signs Probiotics May NOT Be Right​

SituationConcern
SIBO (small intestinal bacterial overgrowth)May worsen symptoms
Severe bloating from fiberAddress underlying issue first
ImmunocompromisedRisk of infection from live organisms
Severe acute illnessNot priority, may not tolerate
When diet is terribleFix foundation first

Response Signs​

Positive Response:

  • Improved bowel regularity
  • Reduced bloating
  • Better digestion
  • Fewer infections
  • Improved mood (psychobiotics)

Negative Response (May Need to Stop):

  • Increased bloating
  • New or worse symptoms
  • No change after 4-8 weeks
  • Signs of SIBO worsening

🎯 Practical Application​

Choosing and Using Probiotics

Matching Strains to Needs​

For Antibiotic-Associated Diarrhea:

StrainEvidence
Saccharomyces boulardiiStrong—survives antibiotics
Lactobacillus rhamnosus GGStrong
Lactobacillus acidophilus LA-5Moderate

For IBS:

StrainEvidence
Bifidobacterium infantis 35624Strong (Align)
VSL#3 (multi-strain)Moderate
Lactobacillus plantarum 299vModerate

For Immune Support:

StrainEvidence
Lactobacillus rhamnosus GGModerate
Lactobacillus paracaseiModerate
Bifidobacterium lactis BB-12Moderate

For Mood (Psychobiotics):

StrainEvidence
Bifidobacterium longum 1714Emerging
Lactobacillus helveticus R0052Emerging
Lactobacillus rhamnosus JB-1Animal evidence

For Vaginal Health:

StrainEvidence
Lactobacillus rhamnosus GR-1Strong
Lactobacillus reuteri RC-14Strong
Lactobacillus crispatusStrong
## 📸 What It Looks Like

Sample Protocol: During Antibiotics​

During Course:

  • Probiotic: Saccharomyces boulardii OR Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG
  • Dose: 20-50 billion CFU
  • Timing: 2-3 hours away from antibiotic
  • Plus: Fermented food daily if tolerated

After Course:

  • Continue probiotic for 2-4 weeks
  • Increase fermented foods
  • High-fiber diet to feed returning bacteria
  • Consider multi-strain probiotic

Sample Protocol: General Gut Support​

Week 1-2:

  • Food-based probiotics daily (yogurt, kefir, or fermented vegetables)
  • Assess tolerance
  • Note any changes

Week 3-8:

  • Add targeted probiotic if desired (match to need)
  • Continue food-based sources
  • 4-8 week trial minimum

Ongoing:

  • Maintain food-based probiotics
  • Cycle supplements periodically if using
  • Focus on prebiotic foods (fiber)

Daily Probiotic Integration​

MealProbiotic Source
BreakfastYogurt or kefir
LunchSmall serving sauerkraut/kimchi
DinnerMiso soup or tempeh
SupplementIf using, with a meal
## 🚀 Getting Started

Week 1: Assessment​

  • Identify your goal (why do you want probiotics?)
  • Assess current fermented food intake
  • Note any contraindications (SIBO, immune issues)
  • Research strain for your need

Week 2-4: Food First​

  • Add daily fermented food
  • Notice tolerance and effects
  • Build this as foundation
  • Assess if supplement needed

Week 5-8: Supplement Trial (If Needed)​

  • Choose targeted strain for your goal
  • Start at recommended dose
  • Track effects (digestion, symptoms)
  • Continue food-based sources

Week 9+: Evaluate​

  • Assess: Is it helping?
  • If yes: Continue or maintain
  • If no: Different strain or investigate further
  • Build sustainable approach
## 🔧 Troubleshooting

Common Probiotic Challenges​

"I get more bloated with probiotics"

  • May indicate SIBO
  • Try spore-based probiotics (different mechanism)
  • Try lower dose
  • May need to address gut first

"I tried probiotics and nothing happened"

  • May be wrong strain for your issue
  • May need longer trial (4-8 weeks)
  • Diet may matter more for you
  • May not have the issue probiotics address

"There are too many options"

  • Match strain to specific need
  • Food sources are valid starting point
  • Quality brands narrow choices
  • Ask practitioner if stuck

"I can't afford supplements"

  • Food sources are effective
  • Yogurt with live cultures is affordable
  • Homemade fermented foods very cheap
  • Prioritize fiber/prebiotics (feeds existing bacteria)

"Probiotics work but only while I take them"

  • This is normal—most don't colonize
  • Continue if helpful OR
  • Focus on prebiotic foods to feed resident bacteria
  • Diet creates lasting change
## 🤖 For Mo

AI Coach Guidance​

Assessment:

  1. "Why are you interested in probiotics?"
  2. "Have you tried any before? What happened?"
  3. "Any digestive symptoms like bloating or irregular bowels?"
  4. "Are you taking or recently took antibiotics?"
  5. "Any immune issues or conditions?"

Key Coaching Points:

  • Strain specificity matters
  • Food sources are valid
  • More CFUs isn't always better
  • 4-8 week trial minimum
  • Not for everyone (SIBO, etc.)

Common Misconceptions:

  • "All probiotics are the same" → Strains matter
  • "More is better" → Dose research varies
  • "They'll fix my gut" → Part of approach, not magic
  • "I need expensive supplements" → Food sources work

Example Scenarios:

  1. "I'm starting antibiotics":

    • Saccharomyces boulardii (survives antibiotics)
    • 20-50 billion CFU
    • 2-3 hours away from antibiotic
    • Continue 2 weeks after

  2. "I have IBS":

    • Consider Bifidobacterium infantis 35624 (Align)
    • 4-8 week trial
    • Address diet and stress too
    • May need professional guidance

  3. "I just want general gut health":

    • Start with fermented foods daily
    • May not need supplements
    • Fiber (prebiotics) often more important
    • Consider quality multi-strain if desired
## âť“ Common Questions

Q: Do probiotics permanently change my microbiome? A: Generally no. Most probiotic strains pass through without permanent colonization. Benefits occur while taking them and shortly after. For lasting change, focus on diet (especially fiber) which feeds your resident bacteria.

Q: Should I take probiotics every day? A: For continued benefits, yes—since most don't colonize permanently. However, food-based probiotics (fermented foods) daily may be sufficient for general health without supplements.

Q: Can probiotics make things worse? A: Yes, in some situations. People with SIBO may worsen with certain probiotics. Immunocompromised individuals can develop infections from live organisms. If symptoms worsen, stop and evaluate.

Q: Are more strains better? A: Not necessarily. Sometimes a single well-researched strain for your specific issue outperforms a multi-strain with less research. Quality and appropriateness matter more than quantity.

Q: Do I need refrigerated probiotics? A: Depends on the product. Some strains are formulated for shelf stability and survive fine at room temperature. Others require refrigeration. Follow product guidelines.

## âś… Quick Reference

Probiotic Decision Guide​

SituationSuggested Approach
General healthFermented foods daily
During antibioticsSaccharomyces boulardii or LGG
IBSBifidobacterium infantis 35624
Vaginal healthLactobacillus rhamnosus GR-1
Mood supportTargeted psychobiotic strains
SIBOAvoid most probiotics initially

Quality Checklist​

  • Full strain identification (genus, species, strain)
  • CFU guaranteed at expiration
  • Reputable manufacturer
  • Proper storage maintained
  • Matches research for your need

💡 Key Takeaways​

Essential Insights
  1. Strain specificity matters—research on one strain doesn't apply to others
  2. More CFUs isn't always better—follow strain-specific research
  3. Most don't permanently colonize—benefits require ongoing intake
  4. Food sources are valid—fermented foods provide beneficial bacteria
  5. Not for everyone—SIBO, immune issues may contraindicate
  6. Match to your need—different strains for different purposes
  7. Give adequate trial—4-8 weeks minimum to assess
## đź“š Sources
  • International Scientific Association for Probiotics and Prebiotics (ISAPP) Guidelines Tier A
  • Cochrane Reviews on Probiotics Tier A
  • World Gastroenterology Organisation Probiotic Guidelines Tier A
  • McFarland - "Probiotics for Antibiotic-Associated Diarrhea" Review Tier A

🔗 Connections​