Skip to main content

Therapy Approaches

Evidence-based therapy modalities—understanding your options and finding what works for you.

📖 The Story​

Click to expand

When Alex finally decided to try therapy, he was overwhelmed. His insurance listed dozens of therapists with acronyms after their names—CBT, DBT, EMDR, ACT, IFS. What did any of this mean? Would he have to lie on a couch and talk about his mother?

His first therapist used a cognitive approach, helping him identify negative thought patterns. It was helpful for his everyday anxiety, but something still felt unfinished. When he mentioned childhood trauma, she referred him to a colleague trained in EMDR.

The EMDR therapist helped him process memories that talk therapy hadn't touched. The combination—cognitive skills from one approach, trauma processing from another—gave him tools and healing.

"I didn't know therapy had different 'flavors,'" Alex says. "Finding the right approach—and the right therapist—made all the difference. The first one helped me manage day-to-day. The second one helped me heal old wounds."

The lesson: Not all therapy is the same. Different approaches work for different problems. Finding the right fit matters as much as finding the right therapist.

🚶 The Journey​

Understanding Therapy Types

Matching Approach to Need:

If You're Dealing WithConsider
Anxiety, depressionCBT, ACT, IPT
Trauma, PTSDEMDR, CPT, PE
Intense emotionsDBT
Relationship issuesIPT, Psychodynamic, EFT
Chronic depressionCBASP, BA, Psychodynamic
Personal growthACT, IFS, Psychodynamic
Recurrent depressionMBCT

🧠 The Science​

How Therapy Works

The Science of Therapeutic Change​

Common Factors (account for ~30-40% of change):

  • Therapeutic alliance (relationship with therapist)
  • Empathy and understanding
  • Positive expectations
  • Agreement on goals

Specific Factors (account for ~15-20% of change):

  • Particular techniques of each approach
  • Skills taught
  • Processing methods
  • Homework/practice

What This Means:

  • The relationship matters as much as the technique
  • All legitimate therapies share effective elements
  • Specific approaches may work better for specific problems
  • Your engagement is crucial

Research Evidence​

ApproachEvidence LevelBest For
CBTVery StrongAnxiety, depression, many conditions
DBTStrongBPD, emotion dysregulation
EMDRStrongTrauma, PTSD
PE/CPTStrongPTSD
IPTStrongDepression
ACTGrowingVarious
MBCTStrongDepression recurrence prevention
PsychodynamicModerateLong-standing patterns

Meta-analysis findings:

  • Therapy is effective (better than no treatment)
  • Different approaches often have similar outcomes
  • Matching approach to problem improves outcomes
  • Therapist factors matter significantly
## 👀 Signs & Signals

Signs You Might Benefit from Therapy​

Consider therapy if:

  • Struggling for 2+ weeks with mental health symptoms
  • Problems affecting work, relationships, daily life
  • Feeling stuck despite self-help efforts
  • Going through major life transitions
  • Processing trauma or loss
  • Wanting personal growth
  • Seeking professional support

Signs the Approach Is Working​

Positive SignsTimeline
Feel heard and understoodSessions 1-3
Beginning to understand patternsWeeks 2-6
Practicing new skillsWeeks 3-8
Symptoms reducingWeeks 4-12
Handling situations betterWeeks 6-16
Maintaining gainsMonths 3-6+

Signs to Consider a Different Approach​

  • No progress after 8-12 sessions
  • Don't feel connected to therapist
  • Approach doesn't fit your problem
  • Feel worse with no improvement
  • Therapist not addressing your goals
  • You're doing all the work with no guidance

🎯 Practical Application​

Major Therapy Approaches

Cognitive Behavioral Therapy​

The Foundation:

  • Thoughts, feelings, and behaviors are interconnected
  • Changing thoughts and behaviors changes feelings
  • Present-focused and skills-based
  • Structured, time-limited
  • Homework between sessions

How It Works:

Situation
    ↓
Automatic Thought (often negative)
    ↓
Emotion
    ↓
Behavior
    ↓
Consequences (often reinforce thoughts)

In CBT, you learn to:

  1. Identify automatic negative thoughts
  2. Examine evidence for and against
  3. Generate more balanced thoughts
  4. Test beliefs through behavioral experiments
  5. Build adaptive coping behaviors

Session Structure:

  • Check-in and agenda
  • Review homework
  • Work on current issues
  • Teach/practice skills
  • Assign homework

Best For:

  • Anxiety disorders
  • Depression
  • OCD
  • PTSD
  • Eating disorders
  • Insomnia (CBT-I)
  • Many other conditions

Timeline: Often 12-20 sessions

## 📸 What It Looks Like

What to Expect in Therapy​

First Session:

  • Paperwork and consent
  • Therapist asks about concerns, history, goals
  • You ask questions too
  • Initial impressions
  • Plan for treatment

Typical Session (CBT example):

TimeActivity
0-5 minCheck-in, set agenda
5-15 minReview homework, discuss week
15-40 minWork on main issues, skills practice
40-50 minSummarize, assign homework

Between Sessions:

  • Homework/practice
  • Apply skills to daily life
  • Track mood or behaviors
  • Note what to discuss next time

Making the Most of Therapy​

Do:

  • Be honest (even when hard)
  • Complete homework
  • Practice skills between sessions
  • Bring up what's important
  • Give feedback to therapist
  • Give it time (8+ sessions)

Don't:

  • Expect magic/instant fixes
  • Wait for therapist to guess problems
  • Skip sessions regularly
  • Hold back important information
  • Expect therapist to fix you (it's collaborative)
## 🚀 Getting Started

Week 1: Preparation​

  • Clarify what you want help with
  • Research therapy types for your concerns
  • Check insurance coverage
  • Identify potential therapists

Week 2: Find Therapist​

  • Use Psychology Today, insurance list, referrals
  • Look for specialists in your issue
  • Check credentials and approach
  • Contact 2-3 potential therapists

Week 3: First Appointment​

  • Prepare questions for therapist
  • Complete any intake paperwork
  • Attend first session
  • Assess initial fit

Week 4-8: Engagement​

  • Give approach fair trial (8+ sessions)
  • Complete homework assignments
  • Track progress
  • Communicate with therapist about fit

Ongoing​

  • Continue consistent attendance
  • Apply skills outside sessions
  • Discuss ending when appropriate
  • Plan for maintenance/prevention
## 🔧 Troubleshooting

Common Therapy Challenges​

"It doesn't seem to be helping"

  • How long have you tried? (Give 8-12 sessions)
  • Are you doing homework/practicing?
  • Have you told therapist it's not working?
  • May need different approach or therapist
  • Progress is often slow and nonlinear

"I don't connect with my therapist"

  • Alliance matters—consider change
  • But first, tell them (can improve)
  • Some discomfort is normal
  • Give it 3-4 sessions minimum
  • Trust your gut after fair trial

"I can't afford therapy"

  • Sliding scale therapists
  • Community mental health centers
  • Training clinics (supervised students)
  • Online therapy (often cheaper)
  • Employee assistance programs
  • Support groups (often free)

"I don't know which approach I need"

  • Start with issue-matched approach
  • CBT is good general starting point
  • Therapist can help determine
  • Can try different approaches
  • Many therapists integrate approaches

"It's too painful to talk about"

  • Pacing is important
  • Good therapist won't push too fast
  • Can use trauma-specific approaches
  • Avoidance may be maintaining problem
  • Discuss concerns with therapist

"I've been in therapy forever with no progress"

  • Review goals—what are you working on?
  • Consider different approach
  • May need more structured therapy
  • Discuss directly with therapist
  • Consider consultation with another professional
## 🤖 For Mo

AI Coach Guidance​

Assessment Questions:

  1. "What are you hoping therapy could help with?"
  2. "Have you been to therapy before? What was that like?"
  3. "Do you have a sense of what type of therapy might fit?"
  4. "What concerns or hesitations do you have about therapy?"
  5. "What would success in therapy look like for you?"

Key Coaching Points:

  • Therapy is effective and evidence-based
  • Different approaches work for different problems
  • The relationship with therapist matters
  • It takes time (8+ sessions minimum)
  • Engagement and homework matter

Important Boundaries:

  • Mo is not therapy
  • Cannot recommend specific therapists
  • Cannot diagnose conditions
  • Encourage professional help for serious concerns

Example Scenarios:

  1. "Should I try therapy?":

    • Normalize therapy
    • Help identify what they'd want help with
    • Explain different options
    • Encourage trying it

  2. "What type of therapy is best for anxiety?":

    • CBT has strongest evidence
    • ACT also effective
    • EMDR if trauma-related
    • Therapist match matters too
    • Encourage consultation

  3. "Therapy isn't working":

    • How long tried?
    • What approach?
    • Doing homework?
    • Discussed with therapist?
    • May need different approach or therapist
## ❓ Common Questions

Q: How do I choose between therapy types? A: Match to your main concern (CBT for anxiety/depression, EMDR/CPT for trauma, DBT for emotion regulation). But also consider what resonates with you. Many therapists integrate approaches. A good therapist can help determine fit.

Q: How long does therapy take? A: Varies widely. Short-term structured therapies (CBT, EMDR) often 8-20 sessions. Longer-term approaches may be months to years. Depends on goals, severity, and approach.

Q: How do I know if my therapist is good? A: You feel heard and respected. They have training in evidence-based approaches for your issues. You're making progress (even if slow). They seek feedback and adjust. Credentials are appropriate.

Q: Can I do multiple types of therapy? A: Yes, sometimes sequentially (CBT for skills, then EMDR for trauma) or even concurrently (individual + group). Discuss coordination with providers.

Q: Is online therapy as effective? A: Research suggests comparable effectiveness for many conditions. May be more accessible. Some approaches (trauma work) may be better in person. Personal preference matters.

Q: What if I don't want to talk about my past? A: Many approaches (CBT, DBT, BA) focus primarily on present. You don't have to explore past if you don't want to. Some issues may benefit from trauma processing when ready.

## ✅ Quick Reference

Therapy Approach Quick Guide​

ApproachFocusSessionsBest For
CBTThoughts & behaviors12-20Anxiety, depression
DBTEmotion regulation6-12 monthsBPD, intense emotions
EMDRTrauma processing8-12+PTSD, trauma
ACTAcceptance & valuesVariesAvoidance, various
IPTRelationships12-16Depression
MBCTMindfulness + CBT8 weeksDepression recurrence

Finding a Therapist​

ResourceAccess
Psychology Todaypsychologytoday.com
Insurance providerMember portal
Primary careAsk for referral
SAMHSAfindtreatment.gov
Open PathLow-cost option

💡 Key Takeaways​

Essential Insights
  1. Not all therapy is the same—different approaches for different problems
  2. The relationship matters—therapist fit is crucial
  3. CBT has strongest evidence—good starting point for anxiety/depression
  4. Trauma needs trauma therapy—EMDR, CPT, PE are gold standard
  5. Give it time—8+ sessions before judging effectiveness
  6. Your engagement matters—homework and practice are essential
  7. It's okay to switch—if it's not working after fair trial
## 📚 Sources
  • APA Division 12 - Research-Supported Treatments Tier A
  • Wampold - "The Great Psychotherapy Debate" Tier B
  • NICE Guidelines on Depression and Anxiety Treatments Tier A
  • Shapiro - EMDR Research Foundation Tier A
  • Linehan - DBT Research Tier A

🔗 Connections​