Carbohydrates

The energy macro — your body's preferred fuel for brain and intense activity.

---

📖 The Story: The Most Misunderstood Macro

Meet Sarah and Mike. Both want to lose weight. Sarah goes keto — cuts carbs to under 20g a day, eats bacon and eggs, avocados and steak. For two weeks, she feels incredible: clear-headed, rapidly losing weight, convinced she's found the answer. Then week three hits. She's exhausted, her workouts suffer, she's constipated, and she's dreaming about bread.

Mike takes a different approach. He keeps eating carbs but makes smarter choices — swaps white rice for quinoa, adds vegetables to every meal, stops drinking soda. He loses weight more slowly, but consistently. His energy stays stable. He's still eating pasta on Fridays.

Six months later? Mike's maintained his loss. Sarah regained most of her weight within two months of "going back to normal" — because keto wasn't sustainable for her lifestyle.

Here's what this story reveals: The best carb approach is one you can maintain. Neither person was "wrong" — but Sarah's approach wasn't matched to her reality.

No macronutrient has been more demonized — and more misunderstood — than carbohydrates. "Carbs make you fat." "Carbs spike insulin." "Carbs are addictive." The low-carb movement has convinced many that carbohydrates are the enemy.

Here's the truth: carbs aren't inherently good or bad. They're a tool.

Your brain runs primarily on glucose — about 120 grams per day. Your muscles store glycogen (from carbs) to fuel intense exercise. Elite athletes deliberately carb-load before competition. Fiber, a carbohydrate, is essential for gut health and associated with reduced mortality.

The problem isn't carbohydrates — it's which carbs, how much, and in what context. A bowl of oatmeal with berries isn't the same as a can of soda, even though both are "carbs." The key is understanding how different carbohydrates affect your body and matching your intake to your activity level and goals.

---

🚶 The Journey: What Happens When You Eat Carbs

Let's follow a sweet potato from your plate through your entire body. Understanding this journey helps you make smarter choices about which carbs to eat and when.

The First Few Minutes: Breakdown Begins in Your Mouth

You take a bite of sweet potato. As you chew, something interesting happens: your saliva contains an enzyme called salivary amylase that immediately starts breaking down starches into simpler sugars.

Try this experiment: chew a plain cracker for 30 seconds without swallowing. It starts to taste sweet — that's amylase converting starch to sugar right in your mouth.

This is why how you eat matters. Wolfing down food means less time for this initial breakdown, putting more burden on later stages.

Minutes 5-30: The Stomach Pause

The chewed sweet potato hits your stomach. Here, amylase gets deactivated by stomach acid — carb digestion essentially pauses while your stomach churns and mixes the food with digestive juices.

Fat and fiber slow this stage. A baked sweet potato with butter exits your stomach more slowly than mashed white potato. This is why adding fat to carbs reduces blood sugar spikes — it's literally slowing the delivery to your small intestine.

The stomach takes anywhere from 30 minutes to several hours to empty, depending on the meal.

Hours 1-3: Where the Real Action Happens

The partially digested carbs enter your small intestine — and this is where the magic happens.

Your pancreas releases pancreatic amylase, which continues breaking starches into smaller chains. Then enzymes on the intestinal wall — maltase, sucrase, lactase — finish the job, converting everything into single sugar molecules: glucose, fructose, and galactose.

Here's the key: only single sugars can cross into your bloodstream. Every carb you eat, from table sugar to quinoa, ends up as these basic units.

Different carbs break down at different speeds:

• Simple sugars (candy, soda): Already simple → rapid absorption
• White bread: Quickly broken down → fast absorption
• Whole grains: Fiber and structure slow breakdown → gradual absorption
• Legumes: Dense structure + fiber → slowest absorption

The Glucose Highway: Into Your Blood

Glucose and other sugars cross the intestinal wall through specialized transporters and enter your bloodstream. Your blood sugar rises.

This is when insulin enters the story.

Your pancreas senses rising blood glucose and releases insulin — a hormone that acts like a key, unlocking cells to let glucose in. Without insulin, glucose would pile up in your blood while your cells starved (this is essentially Type 1 diabetes).

Where Does the Glucose Go?

Once insulin opens the doors, glucose has several destinations:

1. Immediate energy (~20%) Cells that need energy right now — your brain, active muscles, organs — burn glucose immediately through glycolysis and the citric acid cycle, producing ATP (energy currency).

2. Muscle glycogen storage (~40%) Your muscles are glucose warehouses. They can store about 400-500g of glycogen for future use. This is your reserve tank for exercise.

3. Liver glycogen storage (~15%) Your liver stores ~100-120g of glycogen, but unlike muscle glycogen, the liver can release glucose back into the bloodstream to maintain blood sugar between meals and overnight.

4. Fat storage (variable) If glycogen stores are full and you're eating more than you need, excess glucose gets converted to fat through de novo lipogenesis. This process is actually inefficient — your body prefers to store dietary fat as body fat. But chronically overeating carbs does contribute to fat gain.

Fructose Takes a Different Path

Fructose (from fruit, table sugar, high-fructose corn syrup) doesn't follow the same route. It goes almost entirely to your liver, which processes it directly.

In moderate amounts (whole fruit), this is fine — the liver converts it to glucose or glycogen. In excess (soda, candy, lots of fruit juice), it can overwhelm the liver and contribute to fatty liver disease and metabolic issues.

This is why fruit isn't the same as fruit juice: Whole fruit has fiber that slows absorption and practical limits on how much you'll eat. You might eat one apple; you probably won't eat five. But drinking the equivalent of five apples in juice? Easy.

The Other 20 Hours: Maintaining Blood Sugar

After a meal, blood glucose peaks around 30-60 minutes, then gradually returns to baseline over 2-3 hours (faster for simple carbs, slower for complex).

Between meals, your body works to keep blood sugar stable:

• Liver releases stored glycogen → glucose
• Hormones like glucagon oppose insulin to prevent blood sugar dropping too low
• If carbs are very low, the liver makes glucose from protein and fat (gluconeogenesis)

This system evolved to handle feast and famine — storing fuel when available, rationing it when scarce. The problem today is that feast mode never ends.

---

🧠 The Science: How Carbohydrates Work

Carbohydrate Chemistry Basics

All carbohydrates are made of sugar molecules. The difference is how many and how they're linked together.

Type	Structure	Examples	Digestion Speed
Monosaccharides	Single sugar	Glucose, fructose, galactose	Absorbed directly — fastest
Disaccharides	Two sugars	Sucrose (table sugar), lactose (milk), maltose	Quick breakdown — fast
Oligosaccharides	3-10 sugars	Some fibers, prebiotics (GOS, FOS)	Fermented by bacteria — not absorbed
Polysaccharides	Many sugars	Starch, glycogen, cellulose	Slow breakdown or indigestible

What Carbohydrates Do

Key functions:

1. Immediate energy — Glucose is the fastest fuel source, essential for high-intensity activity
2. Brain function — The brain uses ~120g glucose daily (can partially adapt to ketones)
3. Glycogen storage — Muscles and liver store glucose for later use
4. Protein sparing — Adequate carbs prevent muscle breakdown for energy
5. Gut health — Fiber feeds beneficial bacteria, produces health-promoting compounds

Fiber: The Underrated Carb

Fiber is the part of carbohydrates that humans can't digest — but our gut bacteria can. This distinction makes it incredibly important.

Fiber Types

Soluble vs. Insoluble Fiber

Type	What It Does	Found In	Key Benefits
Soluble	Dissolves in water, forms gel	Oats, beans, apples, psyllium	Slows digestion, lowers cholesterol, feeds gut bacteria
Insoluble	Adds bulk, doesn't dissolve	Wheat bran, vegetables, whole grains	Speeds transit, prevents constipation

Both types are important. Most high-fiber foods contain both. The key is getting enough total fiber — most people don't.

Fermentation & SCFAs

How Fiber Becomes Medicine

When fiber reaches your colon, bacteria ferment it, producing Short-Chain Fatty Acids (SCFAs):

Butyrate is especially important:

• Primary fuel for colon cells
• Strengthens gut barrier
• Reduces inflammation
• May protect against colon cancer
• Improves insulin sensitivity

Research findings (2019 Lancet meta-analysis):

• Each 8g increase in fiber associated with 5-27% reduction in heart disease, Type 2 diabetes, colon cancer
• 25-30g fiber/day associated with lowest disease risk
• Higher fiber = lower all-cause mortality

Resistant Starch: Carbs That Act Like Fiber

Resistant starch is starch that "resists" digestion in the small intestine and reaches the colon intact, where it's fermented like fiber.

Type	Description	Food Sources
RS1	Physically trapped in cell walls	Whole grains, legumes, seeds
RS2	Raw granular starch	Green bananas, raw potatoes, high-amylose corn
RS3	Retrograded starch (cooked then cooled)	Cooked & cooled potatoes, rice, pasta
RS4	Chemically modified	Some commercial food products

For Mo

Practical hack: Cooking and cooling starchy foods increases resistant starch. Cooling potatoes overnight at 4°C increases RS by 2.8x. You can reheat them — the resistant starch largely remains. This means potato salad and cold rice are better for blood sugar than freshly cooked versions. Pasta salad > hot pasta for glycemic response.

Glycogen: Your Carb Storage System

Your body stores carbohydrates as glycogen in muscles and liver. This is your readily available fuel reserve.

Aspect	Muscle Glycogen	Liver Glycogen
Capacity	~400-500g (~1,600-2,000 cal)	~100-120g (~400-500 cal)
Function	Local muscle fuel only	Blood sugar regulation (systemic)
Access	Only by that specific muscle	Can be released into bloodstream
Depletion time	~60-90 min intense exercise	~12-24 hours fasting
Replenishment	24-48 hours with adequate carbs	12-24 hours

Each gram of glycogen stores ~3g of water. This explains:

• Why low-carb diets cause rapid initial weight loss (it's water, not fat)
• Why carb refeeds cause rapid weight gain (it's water, not fat)
• Why athletes can gain 2-4 lbs overnight after carb-loading

Gluconeogenesis: Making Glucose Without Carbs

When carbohydrate intake is very low, your body can make glucose from non-carb sources through gluconeogenesis.

What this means:

• You won't die without dietary carbs (your body can make glucose)
• But gluconeogenesis is metabolically "expensive" and can use muscle protein
• The brain can adapt to use ketones (60-70%) but still needs some glucose
• Athletic performance, especially high-intensity, generally suffers at very low carb intakes

---

👀 Signs & Signals: How to Read Your Body

Your body gives you signals about your carbohydrate status. Learning to read them helps you find your optimal intake.

Signs You Might Need More Carbs

Signal	What's Happening	What To Do
Low energy, especially during workouts	Glycogen depleted, not enough fuel for activity	Add carbs around training
Brain fog, poor concentration	Brain preferentially uses glucose	Add slow-digesting carbs
Intense carb cravings	Body signaling fuel needs	Don't fight it — eat quality carbs
Poor workout recovery	Glycogen not replenishing	Post-workout carbs + protein
Constipation	Low fiber intake	Add fiber-rich carbs (vegetables, whole grains)
Feeling cold, low body temperature	Thyroid function can decrease with very low carbs	Carb refeed or increase baseline
Mood changes, irritability	Serotonin production affected by carbs	Especially relevant if chronically low-carb
Sleep problems	Carbs help tryptophan reach brain	Try carbs at dinner
Muscle loss despite training	Body using protein for energy	Increase carbs to spare protein

Signs You Might Be Eating Too Many Carbs

Signal	What's Happening	What To Do
Energy crashes after meals	Blood sugar spike then crash	Choose lower-GI carbs, add protein/fat
Constant hunger despite eating	Refined carbs don't satiate	Swap for fiber-rich, whole food carbs
Bloating and gas	May be intolerance or excess fermentation	Identify trigger foods, reduce quantity
Difficulty losing fat	May be in calorie surplus	Track intake, reduce portion sizes
Afternoon energy slump	Blood sugar dysregulation	More protein at lunch, fewer refined carbs
Sugar cravings that feel uncontrollable	Blood sugar rollercoaster	Stabilize with protein, fat, fiber

Signs Your Carb Intake Is Right

• Stable energy throughout the day
• Good workout performance and recovery
• Regular, comfortable digestion
• Stable mood
• No intense cravings
• Maintaining or progressing toward body composition goals

Individual Variation

Some people thrive on higher carbs; others feel better with fewer. Factors that influence your optimal intake:

• Activity level — More activity = more carb tolerance and need
• Muscle mass — More muscle = more glycogen storage capacity
• Insulin sensitivity — Better sensitivity = better carb handling
• Genetics — AMY1 gene affects starch digestion (salivary amylase)
• Gut microbiome — Affects how you process different carbs
• Goals — Fat loss, performance, maintenance all have different considerations

---

🎯 Making It Work: Practical Application

How Many Carbs Do You Need?

Unlike protein and fat, there's no essential requirement for carbohydrates — but that doesn't mean you shouldn't eat them. Your needs depend on your activity and goals.

Situation	Carb Target	Example (70kg/154lb person)
Sedentary	2-3 g/kg	140-210g
Light exercise (3x/week)	3-4 g/kg	210-280g
Moderate exercise (5x/week)	4-5 g/kg	280-350g
High volume training	5-7 g/kg	350-490g
Endurance athletes	6-10 g/kg	420-700g
Fat loss (active)	2-4 g/kg	140-280g
Low-carb approach	50-150g/day	—
Ketogenic	<50g/day	—

Match Carbs to Activity

A sedentary office worker and a marathon runner have vastly different carb needs. There's no universal "right" amount — it depends on what you're asking your body to do. Eating like an athlete when you're not training like one leads to problems.

Glycemic Index and Glycemic Load

Glycemic Index (GI)

Glycemic Index

The GI ranks foods 0-100 based on how quickly they raise blood sugar compared to pure glucose (100).

GI Category	Range	Examples
Low	55 or less	Most vegetables, legumes, whole grains, apples, berries
Medium	56-69	Whole wheat bread, sweet potatoes, bananas, oatmeal
High	70+	White bread, white rice, potatoes, watermelon, cornflakes

Limitations of GI:

• Measured in isolation (eating fat/protein changes response)
• Doesn't account for portion size
• Individual variation is significant
• A food's GI can vary by ripeness, cooking method, variety

Glycemic Load (GL)

Glycemic Load

GL accounts for both GI and portion size, making it more practical:

GL = (GI × carbs per serving) ÷ 100

GL Category	Range	Examples
Low	10 or less	Apple (6), carrots (3), lentils (5), strawberries (1)
Medium	11-19	Banana (12), orange juice (12), oatmeal (13)
High	20+	Baked potato (26), white rice serving (23), pasta (20)

Example — Watermelon:

• GI: 72 (high!)
• Carbs per typical serving: 11g
• GL: (72 × 11) ÷ 100 = 8 (low!)

Watermelon is "high GI" but "low GL" because a typical serving has few carbs. This is why GL is more useful practically.

Practical Approach

Don't obsess over GI numbers. Focus on: whole food carbs, eating them with protein and fat, including fiber, and paying attention to how you feel. The context of your overall meal matters more than isolated values.

See Blood Sugar for detailed glycemic management strategies.

Timing Carbs for Your Goals

General Health

Carb Timing for General Health

For most people not doing intense training, timing matters less than:

• Total daily intake
• Carb quality (whole foods over refined)
• Eating with protein and fat

Simple guidelines:

• Include some carbs at each meal for stable energy
• Front-load slightly (more earlier, less at dinner) if you're sedentary
• Include carbs at dinner if you have sleep issues (helps tryptophan)

Around Exercise

Carb Timing for Exercise

Pre-workout (1-4 hours before):

• 1-4g carbs/kg depending on timing and meal size
• Lower fiber and fat for comfort
• Examples: Oatmeal, banana, toast with honey, rice cakes

During (for sessions >60 minutes):

• 30-60g/hour of simple carbs
• Sports drinks, gels, dried fruit, banana
• Not necessary for shorter sessions

Post-workout (0-2 hours after):

• 0.5-1g carbs/kg
• Combine with protein (0.3-0.5g/kg)
• Glycogen synthesis enhanced for 2-4 hours post-exercise
• Less critical timing if not training again within 24 hours

For Fat Loss

Carb Timing for Fat Loss

When calories are restricted, strategic carb placement can help:

Option 1: Carbs around training

• Concentrate carbs before and after workouts
• Lower carb at other meals
• Preserves performance while creating deficit

Option 2: Carbs at dinner

• Helps with satiety and sleep
• Keeps daytime meals protein/fat focused
• Can reduce evening cravings

What matters most:

• Total calorie deficit
• Adequate protein
• Finding an approach you can sustain

Best Carbohydrate Sources

Whole Food Carbs

Food	Carbs/100g	Fiber	Why Choose It
Sweet potato	20g	3g	Beta-carotene, potassium, sustained energy
Oats	66g	10g	Beta-glucan fiber, cholesterol-lowering
Quinoa	21g	3g	Complete protein, all essential amino acids
Brown rice	23g	2g	Versatile, moderate GI, manganese
Legumes	20-25g	6-8g	Protein + fiber combo, very satiating
Berries	10-14g	4-6g	Antioxidants, low sugar, high fiber ratio
Vegetables	3-10g	2-4g	Maximum nutrients per calorie
Whole wheat bread	40g	6g	Choose "100% whole wheat" — check ingredients

Performance Carbs

Food	Carbs	Speed	Best For
White rice	28g/100g	Fast	Post-workout, carb loading
Banana	23g each	Moderate	Pre-workout, during endurance
Dates	75g/100g	Fast	During long sessions, natural energy
White potato	17g/100g	Fast	Post-workout glycogen replenishment
Honey	82g/100g	Fast	During exercise, easy digestion
Sports drinks	6-8g/100ml	Fast	Hydration + fuel during activity
Rice cakes	7g each	Fast	Easy pre-workout, low fiber

Limit These

Food	Issue	Better Alternative
Soda	Liquid sugar, no nutrients, easy to overconsume	Sparkling water, unsweetened tea
Candy	Pure sugar, no satiety	Fruit, dark chocolate
White bread	Low fiber, rapid glucose spike	Whole grain bread
Pastries	Sugar + refined flour + fat	Oatmeal with fruit
Sugary cereals	Marketing to kids, sugar bombs	Plain oats, eggs
Fruit juice	Fiber removed, concentrated sugar	Whole fruit

These aren't "poison" — but they provide little nutrition for their calories and are easy to overeat.

---

📸 What It Looks Like: Concrete Examples

Abstract recommendations like "eat 200g of carbs" don't mean much until you see what that looks like in real food.

A Day of ~200g Carbs (Moderate Active Adult)

Breakfast — 45g carbs:

• 1 cup oatmeal, cooked (27g)
• 1 medium banana (23g)
• Handful of blueberries (5g)
• 2 eggs (0g)
• Coffee with splash of milk

Lunch — 55g carbs:

• Large salad with mixed vegetables (10g)
• 1 cup cooked quinoa (39g)
• Grilled chicken breast (0g)
• Olive oil dressing (0g)
• Apple (25g)

Snack — 25g carbs:

• Greek yogurt (8g)
• Small handful of berries (10g)
• Few almonds (3g)

Dinner — 60g carbs:

• Medium sweet potato (26g)
• Large portion of roasted vegetables (15g)
• Salmon fillet (0g)
• 1/2 cup brown rice (23g)

Evening (optional) — 15g carbs:

• Small piece of dark chocolate (10g)
• Herbal tea

---

What 50g of Carbs Looks Like

Option	Amount	Notes
Oats (dry)	75g (~3/4 cup)	Plus 10g fiber
Cooked rice	175g (~3/4 cup)	White or brown
Banana	2 medium	Plus potassium
Sweet potato	250g (1 large)	Plus vitamin A
Bread	4 slices	Choose whole grain
Pasta (cooked)	150g (~1 cup)	Al dente = lower GI
Apple	2.5 medium	Plus 6g fiber
Beans (cooked)	250g (~1 cup)	Plus 15g protein, 12g fiber

Low-Carb Day (~75g) Example

Breakfast — 15g carbs:

• 3 eggs scrambled with vegetables (5g)
• 1/2 avocado (6g)
• Coffee with cream (1g)

Lunch — 20g carbs:

• Large salad with grilled chicken (8g)
• Olive oil and vinegar dressing (0g)
• 1/2 cup berries (8g)
• Handful of nuts (4g)

Dinner — 25g carbs:

• Steak or salmon (0g)
• Large portion of roasted broccoli and cauliflower (10g)
• Side salad (5g)
• Small serving of roasted butternut squash (10g)

Snack — 15g carbs:

• Celery with almond butter (5g)
• Small apple (15g)

High-Carb Training Day (~350g) Example

Breakfast — 80g carbs:

• Large bowl of oatmeal with banana and honey (70g)
• Orange juice (25g)
• Toast with jam (25g)

Pre-workout — 40g carbs:

• 2 rice cakes with honey (30g)
• Banana (23g)

Post-workout — 60g carbs:

• Protein shake with banana (25g)
• White rice with chicken (45g)

Lunch — 70g carbs:

• Large pasta serving with meat sauce (65g)
• Side of bread (15g)

Dinner — 80g carbs:

• Large baked potato (45g)
• Corn on the cob (20g)
• Lean protein
• Vegetables

Snack — 20g carbs:

• Fruit (20g)

---

🚀 Getting Started: Finding Your Carb Sweet Spot

Week 1: Baseline Assessment

Task: Track what you're currently eating without changing anything.

Use an app (MyFitnessPal, Cronometer) or write it down. Pay attention to:

• Total daily carbs
• Types of carbs (whole food vs. refined)
• How you feel after different meals
• Energy levels throughout the day

What you'll likely discover:

• More carbs than you thought (or less)
• Most come from a few sources
• Energy correlates with carb timing/type

Week 2: Quality Upgrade

Task: Swap refined carbs for whole food versions.

Don't change amounts yet — just improve quality:

• White bread → whole grain
• White rice → brown rice or quinoa
• Sugary cereal → oatmeal
• Soda → water or unsweetened beverages
• Candy → fruit

Notice how you feel. Whole food carbs digest slower, keeping energy more stable.

Week 3: Adjust Quantity

Task: Match carbs to your actual activity level.

Use the targets from "Making It Work":

• Sedentary: 2-3 g/kg
• Light activity: 3-4 g/kg
• Regular training: 4-5+ g/kg

If you're currently eating much more or less than your target, adjust gradually (50g increments).

Week 4: Fine-Tune Timing

Task: Experiment with when you eat carbs.

Try:

• More carbs earlier in the day
• Carbs concentrated around workouts
• Carbs at dinner for sleep

Note what works for your energy, performance, and preferences.

Week 5+: Personalize

Task: Make it sustainable.

Build a rotation of go-to meals that fit your carb targets. Most people thrive with 10-15 reliable meals they rotate through.

Questions to answer:

• What's your energy like?
• How's your workout performance?
• Are you progressing toward your goals?
• Can you maintain this long-term?

Adjust based on results, not dogma.

---

🔧 Troubleshooting: Common Problems

"I crash after eating carbs"

The issue: Blood sugar spike and crash, usually from refined carbs eaten alone.

Solutions:

1. Add protein and fat — Never eat carbs alone; combine with protein/fat to slow absorption
2. Choose lower-GI options — Whole grains, legumes, vegetables instead of refined
3. Reduce portion size — Smaller servings = smaller spikes
4. Add fiber — Fiber slows digestion; vegetables with every meal
5. Check for insulin resistance — If chronic, see a doctor

---

"I can't lose weight eating carbs"

The issue: Probably eating too many calories overall, not specifically carbs.

Solutions:

1. Track accurately — Most people underestimate intake; measure and log
2. Prioritize protein first — Higher protein = higher satiety, easier deficit
3. Choose high-fiber carbs — More filling per calorie
4. Don't drink calories — Soda, juice, fancy coffee add up fast
5. Consider timing — Some people do better with carbs earlier or around exercise

---

"I'm constipated on low-carb"

The issue: Most fiber comes from carb-containing foods. Cut carbs, cut fiber.

Solutions:

1. Prioritize low-carb fiber sources — Vegetables, avocado, nuts, seeds, berries
2. Add psyllium husk — Fiber supplement that doesn't add net carbs
3. Stay hydrated — Low-carb diets are diuretic; drink more water
4. Consider magnesium — Often low on low-carb; helps with regularity
5. Gradually transition — Don't go from 300g to 50g overnight

---

"I feel terrible on low-carb (keto flu)"

The issue: Electrolyte depletion and adaptation period.

Solutions:

1. Salt your food liberally — You excrete more sodium on low-carb
2. Supplement electrolytes — Sodium, potassium, magnesium
3. Stay very hydrated — But don't over-hydrate without electrolytes
4. Give it time — Adaptation takes 2-4 weeks
5. Reconsider if needed — Low-carb isn't for everyone; that's okay

---

"I can't stop eating carbs once I start"

The issue: Refined carbs can trigger a "more is more" response; blood sugar swings drive cravings.

Solutions:

1. Don't start with refined carbs — Have protein/fat first
2. Choose whole food carbs — Much harder to overeat oatmeal than cookies
3. Don't keep trigger foods at home — Easier to resist at the store than the pantry
4. Address underlying issues — Stress eating, emotional eating, sleep deprivation
5. Allow planned treats — Complete restriction often backfires

---

"Low-carb killed my workout performance"

The issue: High-intensity exercise relies heavily on glycogen; low carb depletes it.

Solutions:

1. Time carbs around training — Targeted ketogenic approach (TKD)
2. Allow more time to adapt — Full fat-adaptation takes weeks to months
3. Accept some performance trade-off — Or increase carbs
4. Consider cyclical approach — Low-carb most days, higher on heavy training days
5. Evaluate if low-carb is right for your goals — Performance athletes usually need carbs

---

❓ Common Questions

Do carbs make you fat?

No — excess calories make you fat. You can gain weight eating too much of anything. Carbs are often overeaten because refined carbs are calorie-dense and not very filling. But in a calorie deficit, carbs don't prevent fat loss. Many lean people eat high-carb diets.

Should I avoid carbs after 6pm?

No. There's nothing magical about evening carbs. Your body processes them the same regardless of time. Some evidence suggests carbs at dinner may help sleep quality (tryptophan uptake). What matters is total daily intake, not timing.

Are "net carbs" a real thing?

Partially. Net carbs = total carbs - fiber (and sometimes sugar alcohols). Since fiber isn't absorbed as glucose, subtracting it makes sense for blood sugar purposes. However, fiber still provides some calories through bacterial fermentation, and labeling varies. Use as a rough guide.

Do I need carbs to build muscle?

Not strictly, but they help. You can build muscle on low-carb diets, but training performance typically benefits from carbs. Glycogen-depleted muscles fatigue faster, limiting training volume. Most bodybuilders eat moderate-to-high carbs during building phases.

What about "good carbs" vs. "bad carbs"?

Better framing: Whole food carbs vs. refined carbs. Whole food carbs (vegetables, fruits, legumes, whole grains) come with fiber, nutrients, and slower digestion. Refined carbs (sugar, white flour products) are calorie-dense, easy to overeat, and spike blood sugar. Neither is poison — context and quantity matter.

Is fruit bad because of sugar?

No. Fruit contains fructose, but it's packaged with fiber, water, vitamins, and antioxidants. Studies consistently show fruit consumption associates with better health outcomes. The fiber slows absorption and increases satiety. Fruit juice is different — without fiber, it's more like sugar water.

How many carbs kick you out of ketosis?

Generally 20-50g net carbs daily, but individual variation is significant. Athletes can often eat more and stay in ketosis. Whether ketosis is necessary for your goals is a separate question — many benefits attributed to keto come from weight loss itself, not specifically ketosis.

---

⚖️ Where Research Disagrees

Low-Carb vs. High-Carb for Fat Loss

Meta-analyses show no significant difference in fat loss when protein and calories are matched. Both approaches work. Individual adherence and preference often determine success. Some people genuinely feel and perform better on one vs. the other.

Practical stance: Choose the approach you can sustain. If you love bread and pasta, extreme low-carb will be miserable. If you feel great on keto, do that.

Carbs and Insulin: The Controversy

The "carbs → insulin → fat storage" model (carbohydrate-insulin model of obesity) is debated. Critics point out:

• Protein also raises insulin
• Insulin is also anti-catabolic (prevents muscle breakdown)
• Overfeeding studies show similar fat gain regardless of carb/fat ratio

Practical stance: Chronic hyperinsulinemia is problematic, but normal insulin responses to meals are healthy. Focus on overall diet quality and calorie balance.

Optimal Carb Intake for Longevity

Some research (2018 Lancet study) suggests moderate carb intake (40-55% of calories) associates with lowest mortality. Very low (<40%) and very high (>70%) intakes both showed higher risk. However, carb quality likely matters more than quantity — low-carb with animal protein vs. plant protein had different outcomes.

Practical stance: Moderate intake of whole food carbs is probably safest for most people.

Glycemic Index: Does It Matter?

Whether GI matters for weight loss is debated. For diabetics and blood sugar management, it's more clearly relevant. For general weight loss in metabolically healthy people, overall calorie and protein intake seem more important than GI.

Practical stance: GI is one tool, not the whole toolbox. Eating whole foods naturally tends toward lower GI anyway.

---

✅ Quick Reference

Carb Targets by Activity

Activity Level	g/kg/day	70kg Example
Sedentary	2-3	140-210g
Light exercise	3-4	210-280g
Moderate exercise	4-5	280-350g
Heavy training	5-7+	350-490g+

Glycogen Storage

Location	Capacity	Function
Muscle	400-500g	Local fuel
Liver	100-120g	Blood sugar
Blood	~5g	Immediate use

Fiber Targets

Group	Minimum	Optimal
Women	25g	30-35g
Men	38g	35-40g

Quick Carb Content

Food	~50g Carbs
Oats (dry)	75g
Rice (cooked)	175g
Banana	2 medium
Sweet potato	250g
Bread	4 slices
Pasta (cooked)	150g
Apple	2.5 medium
Beans (cooked)	250g

GI Reference

Category	Range	Examples
Low	≤55	Legumes, most vegetables, berries
Medium	56-69	Oatmeal, sweet potato, banana
High	≥70	White bread, white rice, potato

---

💡 Key Takeaways

Essential Insights

1. Carbs aren't evil — They're your body's preferred fuel, especially for brain and intense activity
2. Quality trumps quantity — Whole food carbs beat refined carbs regardless of diet philosophy
3. Match intake to activity — Sedentary people need fewer carbs; athletes need more
4. Fiber is non-negotiable — Most people get ~15g/day; aim for 25-40g for gut health and satiety
5. The resistant starch hack works — Cook and cool starches for better blood sugar response
6. Context changes everything — Carbs with protein/fat/fiber behave differently than carbs alone
7. Your response is individual — Some thrive on high-carb; others do better with less. Experiment.
8. Sustainability wins — The best carb approach is one you can maintain long-term

---

📚 Sources

Carbohydrates and Health:

• Reynolds A, et al. Carbohydrate quality and human health: a series of systematic reviews and meta-analyses. Lancet. 2019. DOI: 10.1016/S0140-6736(18)31809-9 —

Carbohydrates and Mortality:

• Seidelmann SB, et al. Dietary carbohydrate intake and mortality. Lancet Public Health. 2018. DOI: 10.1016/S2468-2667(18)30135-X —

Glycogen and Exercise:

• Murray B, Rosenbloom C. Fundamentals of glycogen metabolism for coaches and athletes. Nutr Rev. 2018. DOI: 10.1093/nutrit/nuy001 —

Fiber and Gut Health:

• Makki K, et al. The Impact of Dietary Fiber on Gut Microbiota in Host Health and Disease. Cell Host Microbe. 2018. DOI: 10.1016/j.chom.2018.05.012 —

Resistant Starch:

• Robertson TM, et al. Starchy carbohydrates in a healthy diet. Nutrients. 2020. —

Glycemic Index:

• Augustin LSA, et al. Glycemic index, glycemic load and glycemic response: An International Scientific Consensus Summit. Nutr Metab Cardiovasc Dis. 2015. DOI: 10.1016/j.numecd.2015.05.005 —

Low-Carb Diets:

• Bueno NB, et al. Very-low-carbohydrate ketogenic diet v. low-fat diet for long-term weight loss: a meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials. Br J Nutr. 2013. DOI: 10.1017/S0007114513000548 —

See the Sources Library for complete references.

---

🔗 Connections to Other Topics

Within Macronutrients:

• Macronutrients Overview — How carbs fit with protein and fats
• Protein — The priority macro for body composition
• Fats — The other energy macro

Related Topics:

• Blood Sugar — Detailed glycemic management strategies
• Gut Health — Fiber and the microbiome connection
• Meal Timing & Fasting — When to eat carbs

Goals:

• Fat Loss — Carb strategies for weight loss
• Energy & Vitality — Carbs for sustained energy
• Movement & Exercise — Fueling performance

---

For Mo

When coaching users on carbohydrates:

1. Assess activity level first — A sedentary person and an athlete have completely different needs
2. Don't demonize carbs — They're not inherently fattening; context and quantity matter
3. Start with quality, then quantity — Swapping refined for whole food often solves most issues
4. Watch for extremes — Both very high and very low carb can be problematic
5. Match to goals — Fat loss may benefit from lower carb; performance usually needs more
6. Address the real issue — Often "carb problems" are actually refined carb, portion, or overall calorie problems
7. Emphasize fiber — Most people need more; it's the universal recommendation regardless of carb philosophy

Example: If a user says "carbs make me fat," explore: Which carbs? How much? What else are you eating? Often the issue is soda and pastries, not oatmeal and sweet potatoes.